October 1, 2026
Perry Raso stood near the scorched foundation on Succotash Road last May and gave a reporter something specific to hold him to: inspections finished by August 31, doors open again at Potter Pond sometime in September. That was May 20, 2026, the one-year mark since a two-alarm fire took Matunuck Oyster Bar down to nothing. September has just ended, and there's no reopening announcement circulating the way news like that usually does in this town.
What has changed, in the meantime, is what the name Matunuck actually points to on a given weeknight. A single dining room on one pond has become three separate operations, each with its own address and its own construction history, and one of them is tangled up in a legal fight that has nothing to do with rebuilding a restaurant at all.
The fire hit on May 20, 2025, days before Memorial Day weekend, and wiped out the original Succotash Road building entirely. The community response was fast: more than $400,000 raised for a staff of roughly 300. By July 1, 2025, Raso had a tent going up in the marina parking lot across the street, running under a new state law the General Assembly passed that June, one that extended pandemic-era outdoor dining allowances to restaurants shut down by fire, flood, or other disasters rather than just public health orders. That tent came back for its second season on April 15, 2026, and the restaurant's own site still lists it as a spring-and-summer operation at 650 Succotash Road, which means it's a seasonal fixture, not a placeholder waiting on the main building.
Then, in the middle of all that, Raso opened something with no connection to the rebuild. Matunuck Atelier & Market debuted in late January 2026 at 151 Old Tower Hill Road, inside Wakefield's business district rather than anywhere near the water. The restaurant side opened first, serving an expanded menu heavier on crudo, sushi, and house-made pasta than the original's raw-bar classics, with fresh pasta made on site by artisan Gabi Napoli. Raso has said the Atelier concept predates the fire and that he simply moved faster on it once the original building was gone. He's described wanting guests to feel like they'd been transported somewhere closer to a big city dining room, while keeping the seafood quality and pricing familiar.
So as of this month, there are three places carrying the Matunuck name and only one of them still has a building under construction.
| Location | Address | What it is | Status as of late September 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Matunuck Atelier & Market | 151 Old Tower Hill Road, Wakefield | Permanent second restaurant, expanded seafood-pasta-sushi menu | Open nightly, valet parking, market side still not confirmed running |
| Matunuck Marina tent | 650 Succotash Road | Seasonal outdoor dining, original menu | Listed by the restaurant as a spring-and-summer operation |
| Original Matunuck Oyster Bar | 629 Succotash Road, Potter Pond | Rebuilt flagship, still under construction as of the last public update | Owner's August 31 inspection target has passed with no confirmed reopening |
The delay at Potter Pond isn't mysterious once you see what the site required. DiPrete Engineering, which handled surveying, civil, and environmental work on the project alongside GDS Architecture, has described the rebuild as sitting inside the Coastal Resources Management Council's Special Area Management Plan for Potter Pond, an environmentally sensitive designation that comes with its own rulebook. The new building had to be raised eight feet to meet FEMA floodplain elevation requirements, hold to CRMC coastal feature setbacks, and stay under South Kingstown's maximum building height. Raso has said the footprint and feel will stay close to the original, with slightly higher first-floor ceilings so diners get a better view of the pond. He's also joked that he already had the place exactly how he wanted it before the fire forced a redesign anyway.
None of that is unusual for waterfront construction in this stretch of South County. It's also not fast. A building that has to gain elevation, respect a coastal setback, and stay under a height cap doesn't move on a restaurant's marketing calendar, and an August 31 inspection target set in May was always going to be tight.
Here's where it gets easy to conflate two stories that aren't actually the same one. Separate from the restaurant rebuild, Raso has spent years trying to expand his shellfish operation with a scallop farm in Potter Pond, a proposal that drew objections from nearby property owners who argued the shellfish beds would interfere with boating and fishing in the cove. The CRMC approved a scaled-back version in June 2023, cutting 40 percent of the proposed acreage and banning floating cages, but opponents took it to court. On April 1, 2026, Associate Justice Joseph Montalbano sent the whole matter back to the CRMC for additional public hearings. Rhode Island Current reported that a resident group calling itself Save Potter Pond described the ruling as a "clear win" for their side.
That case is about aquaculture permitting, not about whether the dining room reopens. But because it involves the same pond, the same owner, and the same news cycle, it's easy to see a Raso-and-Potter-Pond headline this year and assume it's about the restaurant. It isn't. The scallop farm fight and the building inspection schedule are two different clocks running on two different tracks.
If the question is simply where to eat tonight, the answer hasn't been complicated by any of this. The Atelier has been running steadily since January, open seven nights a week with valet out front and, as of recent listings, a refreshed menu still drawing regular reviews. The market side that Raso described back in January, the one meant to sell fresh pasta, cheese, and Spanish-style small bites alongside the dining room, was still being called "hopefully coming soon" in a dining review published in June by Rhode Island Monthly, months past the spring target first floated for it.
The tent at the marina is doing what it was built to do: keep the original menu and the original staff working through the warmer months while the real building catches up. It was never framed as permanent, and its own listing still ties it to spring and summer rather than a year-round schedule.
The one piece of this that hasn't landed on schedule is the piece with the most weight behind it. A public date, given by the owner himself on the anniversary of the fire, has come and gone without the kind of announcement that usually follows a reopening this size. Nothing about the CRMC hearings changes that timeline directly, but it's one more reason a rebuild inside a coastal setback zone rarely finishes exactly when someone hoped it would.
For now, a table with a view of Potter Pond is still not something you can book at the original address. Old Tower Hill Road is.
Lorraine Perri keeps an eye on the small stuff around Wakefield and South Kingstown, restaurant rebuilds included, because that's the texture that makes a place worth knowing well before anyone needs an agent. Let's Connect if there's a corner of the neighborhood you'd like the full story on.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Connect with a real estate professional who values trust, insight, and personal attention. Every step is guided by a deep understanding of what “home” truly means.